Abstract
Understanding the material deformation behavior in tablet dies is crucial for pharmaceutical development, as it directly influences manufacturability and final tablet properties. Heckel analysis provides a theoretical framework for assessing material deformation during compaction, but its direct correlation with real-world tableting behavior remains an area of interest.
This study introduces a framework for characterizing the deformation mechanisms of pharmaceutical powders. It addresses limitations in conventional methods that rely solely on yield pressure (Py) and strain rate sensitivity (SRS), which fail to fully differentiate elastic and plastic deformation. The heuristic framework for comparative deformation mapping enables differentiation of excipients across the brittle-plastic-elastic space using two parameters from a compaction simulator: Py (from Heckel analysis) and pressure drop (ΔP, from an in-die stress relaxation test). ΔP is treated as a descriptor of time-dependent (viscoplastic and viscoelastic) deformation rather than as a direct measure of elasticity, and its use as an empirical surrogate for elastic character was benchmarked against independent force–displacement elastic energy.
Applied to ten common pharmaceutical excipients, the framework differentiated materials that Py and SRS alone did not resolve (SRS was determined for the four reference materials). Across the ten materials, ΔP tracked elastic energy mainly between excipient classes, whereas within the six lactose grades the relationship was reversed, indicating that ΔP differences within a class reflect time-dependent deformation. The framework is therefore proposed as a comparative, material-sparing screening tool for early-stage excipient selection, not as a predictor of tableting performance or scale-up behavior.
Introduction
Tablets are still the most common oral solid dosage form due to their ease of self-administration, stability, handling convenience, and high patient compliance [1, 2]. They can be manufactured via wet granulation, dry granulation, and direct compaction [3], all of which involve the critical step of powder or granule compaction. For a tablet to achieve coherence, consolidation must occur during the compaction stage of tablet manufacturing. During this consolidation process, density is increased and tensile strength is enhanced by increasing inter-particle contact through fragmentation and plastic deformation [4]. Several mechanisms contribute to consolidation, including inter-particle attractions (van der Waals forces and electrostatic interactions), the formation of solid bridges between particles, mechanical interlocking, and adhesive/cohesive forces at non-movable binder bridges. Together, these mechanisms ensure the structural integrity and performance of the final tablet [4].
Predicting the behavior of a formulation during compaction is challenging due to the diverse components involved. Typical pharmaceutical formulations contain the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API), diluents for flowability and dose uniformity, superdisintegrants for rapid disintegration, and lubricants for manufacturability [5]. Each of these components has a significant impact on the compactibility of the formulation. Thus, a comprehensive understanding of the compaction behavior of these components is essential for optimizing tablet manufacturing processes.
The complexity of tablet manufacturing arises not only from the variety of components in the formulation but also from the numerous subprocesses occurring simultaneously. At low pressures, particle rearrangement takes place as particles shift into the voids within the powder bed, leading to a reduction in volume without causing significant deformation or breakage. As pressure increases, the behavior of the powder becomes more complex, involving mechanisms such as fragmentation (i.e., brittle fracture), plastic deformation, and elastic deformation. These mechanisms jointly enhance the densification and cohesion of the tablet during the compaction process. During the fragmentation process, particles can break into smaller pieces, which then can rearrange to fill the smaller voids in the powder bed. Particles can undergo either plastic or elastic deformation, with the key difference becoming apparent upon pressure release. Elastic deformation allows particles to revert to their original shape through a process called elastic recovery, while plastic deformation results in a permanent change in the particle’s shape. These processes -rearrangement, fragmentation, and deformation- can occur simultaneously, influenced by material properties and compaction stages [4, 6].
Understanding deformation mechanisms is critical not only for optimizing compaction but also for addressing challenges posed by high-speed tableting during the commercial production of pharmaceutics. While tablet development often occurs on slower machines producing fewer tablets, industrial-scale rotary presses can manufacture up to 1 million tablets per hour at punch speeds reaching 1 m/s. At these high speeds, the compaction behavior of the formulation significantly influences the final tablet properties. The sensitivity of materials to the duration of compaction, known as strain rate sensitivity (SRS), plays an important role in determining a tablet’s final properties [7,8,9,10]. SRS is commonly interpreted in the context of how a material behaves under pressure and is linked to material classifications such as brittle, plastic, or elastic. It helps to anticipate how a material will respond to the changes in compaction speed. Several factors influence SRS, including kinematic friction, air entrapment, and material properties. As sliding speed increases during high-speed tableting, the friction between the powder and die rises, typically following a logarithmic trend [11]. Additionally, higher compaction speeds can trap air within the tablet, leading to surface or internal defects and affecting deformation behavior [12]. The intrinsic properties of the powder, such as viscoplasticity and viscoelasticity, also significantly affect SRS [13, 14]. Understanding these factors is crucial for optimizing tablet manufacturing, ensuring consistent product quality, and enabling robust scale-up for commercial production, thereby reducing the risk of batch failure.
Compaction simulators are invaluable for studying deformation mechanisms early in development, providing insights that can help to anticipate scale-up challenges. Their low material consumption is particularly beneficial when API availability is limited (typically in the early stages of pharmaceutical development). Compaction simulators enable Heckel analysis, a widely used model that relates compaction pressure to powder densification, by precisely monitoring pressure and volume changes during compaction. From this Heckel analysis, the yield pressure (Py) is derived, serving as a key indicator of deformation mechanisms and aiding in the understanding of powder compaction and tablet formation [15].
Several physical phenomena (including fragmentation, elastic, plastic, viscoelasticity, and viscoplasticity) have been proposed in the literature to explain the deformation mechanisms of formulations during compaction [7, 9, 13, 14, 16,17,18,19,20,21,22]. Stress relaxation tests are commonly used to investigate viscoelastic and viscoplastic behavior, but distinguishing between these mechanisms (isolating the predominant phenomenon) remains challenging due to their interdependence [7]. These tests, typically performed in the die on a tableting machine, involve compacting the powder to a set pressure, halting the machine (pausing compaction), and monitoring the axial pressure decay over time [13, 14, 17, 22, 23]. The observed pressure drop has been attributed to both viscoplastic and viscoelastic behavior, making interpretation complex. Mazel and Tchoreloff [7] demonstrated that at low pressures, stress relaxation tests effectively assess viscoplastic properties, whereas at high pressures, viscoelastic effects become more dominant, further complicating analysis. Because a single stress relaxation test (one hold at one pressure) cannot separate the two contributions, ΔP is regarded in this work as a composite descriptor of time-dependent deformation.
The interpretation of Py as a classification tool has, however, been the subject of ongoing debate. Yost et al. [24] demonstrated that common brittle-ductile thresholds, including the widely cited Py ≈ 80 MPa boundary, are inherently arbitrary demarcations rather than mechanistically derived boundaries, and cautioned against their use as absolute classifiers. Vreeman and Sun [15] showed that in-die Py correlates strongly with established plasticity parameters obtained from out-of-die Heckel analysis, Kuentz–Leuenberger analysis and macroindentation, and is therefore a reliable, material-sparing measure of powder plasticity; this supports the use of Py as a continuous plasticity descriptor rather than as a binary classifier. The heuristic framework proposed in this study is consistent with both perspectives: Py is used here as a continuous descriptor of brittle character within an empirically calibrated function, not as a binary threshold. This approach preserves the discriminating utility of Py across a broad range of excipients while acknowledging the limitations of rigid classification boundaries. How the present approach differs from existing two-parameter classification maps, including recently published Py–SRS data for commercial polyol grades, is discussed explicitly in the section “Positioning relative to existing classification approaches”.
The aim of this study was therefore to develop and evaluate a heuristic framework that combines Py with the pressure drop (ΔP) from an in-die stress relaxation test into a single comparative deformation map, and to establish how far ΔP can serve as an empirical surrogate for elastic character. Ten filler–binder excipients, including six lactose grades and two MCC grades, were characterized on a compaction simulator; the resulting map positions were then compared with independent force–displacement energy measurements and with deformation behavior reported in the literature.
Download the full article as PDF here A Heuristic Framework
or continue reading here
Materials
Details of the investigated range of materials are summarized in Table I:
Table I Overview of the Investigated Materials: Excipient Name, Manufacturer, Material Type, and Abbreviation
| Excipient name | Manufacturer | Material type | Abbreviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pharmatose® 100M | DFE Pharma | Sieved α-lactose monohydrate | 100M |
| DI-CAFOS® D160 | Budenheim | Dicalcium phosphate dihydrate | DCP |
| Primojel® | DFE Pharma | Sodium starch glycolate | SSG |
| Pharmacel® 102 | DFE Pharma | Microcrystalline cellulose | MCC 102 |
| Pharmacel® 101 | DFE Pharma | Microcrystalline cellulose | MCC 101 |
| SuperTab® 21AN | DFE Pharma | Anhydrous ß-lactose | 21AN |
| SuperTab® 30GR | DFE Pharma | Granulated α-lactose monohydrate | 30GR |
| SuperTab® 11SD | DFE Pharma | Spray dried α-lactose monohydrate | 11SD |
| SuperTab® 14SD | DFE Pharma | Spray dried α-lactose monohydrate | 14SD |
| SuperTab® 40LL | DFE Pharma | Co-processed (anhydrous lactose:lactitol) | 40LL |
Fathollahi, S., Janssen, P.H.M., Patel, A. et al. A Heuristic Framework for Comparative Deformation Mapping of Pharmaceutical Excipients Using Compaction Simulator Data. AAPS PharmSciTech 27, 344 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1208/s12249-026-03577-2
Are you looking for excipients in commercial quantities?












































All4Nutra







